Mapping Metadata

Conceptual Map

In the context of Gabriel García Márquez Linked Open Data, the selected items serve a key role in conveying the narrative in an authentic and meaningful way. The conceptual map is designed to represent the collected data in natural language, outlining both the extracted information and the relationships among entities. In the graph, each item has a different color and is connected to the main subject with a dashed-line. In the other hand, the nodes are represent with the same color of each item highlighting relevant events and individuals linked to the main subject.



E/R Model

In this second model, the information and associations derived from the conceptual map are presented in a more abstract form. Elements such as individuals, dates, topics, and locations are treated as entities, and the links among them are shown as relationships.



Metadata Analysis

A detailed assessment was carried out on the selected items, focusing on how each is described on its original source website. This involved closely analyzing the existing descriptions to identify the key attributes and features emphasized by the sources. Based on this evaluation, appropriate metadata standards were selected to best represent each object. The chosen standards align with the original descriptions, ensuring consistency and completeness in the metadata while accurately reflecting the way the items are presented by their respective sources.


Item Type Source Metadata Standard
Cien años de soledad Manuscript University of Austin Texas,
Henry Ranson Centre
EAD
Coronel Aureliano Buendía Illustration Blanton Museum of Art schema.org
Zona Bananera Image Library of Congress DublinCore
Letter to Bochica Letter University of Austin Texas,
Henry Ranson Centre
EAD
La imaginación como arma política Article Repositorio Documental de la
Universidad de Salamanca
schema.org
One Hundred of Solitudine Seires IMBD MODS
El general en su laberinto Book University of Austin Texas,
Henry Ranson Centre
EAD
Magic in Service of Truth Article The New York Times DublinCore + Terms
Nobel Acceptance Speech Soundtack University of Austin Texas,
Henry Ranson Centre
EAD
The creation of Gabriel García Márquez Documentary IMDB schema.org

Items Description

In this section, the items were revisited to be characterized according to the attributes defined in the Conceptual Model. For each item, a table is presented with three columns representing the components of an RDF triple (subject, predicate, object), where each row corresponds to a distinct statement.


Subject Predicate Object
Article rdf:type schema:Article
Article owl:sameAs https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/21/books/review/
gabriel-garcia-marquezs-work-was-rooted-in-the-real.html
Article crm:P102_has_title Magic in Service of truth
Article dcterms:language Español
Article dcterms:creator Salman Rushdie
Article dcterms:issued 21-5-2014
Article schema:countryOfOrigin New York
Article dcterms:publisher The New York Times
Article dcterms:references Gabriel Garcia Marquez
Article schema:about Magic Realism
Salman Rushdie rdf:type foaf:Person
Salman Rushdie owl:sameAs https://viaf.org/viaf/29540187
Magic Realism rdf:type skos:Concept
Magic Realism owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Magic_realism
New York rdf:type schema:Place
New York owl:sameAs https://www.geonames.org/5128581/new-york-city.html
The New York Times rdf:type schema:Periodical
The New York Times owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q9684
Subject Predicate Object
Book General rdf:type schema:Book
Book General dcterms:creator Gabriel Garcia Marquez
Book General crm:P102_has_title El general en su laberinto
Book General dcterms:created 1988
Book General dcterms:extent 247 pages
Book General schema:genre Novels
Book General dcterms:language Spanish
Book General crm:P52_has_current_owner HRC, University of Texas
Book General crm:P55_has_current_location Austin
Book General dcterms:isPartOf Gabriel Garcia Marquez Collection
Book General dcterms:subject Simon Bolivar
Book General schema:about Politics
Gabriel Garcia Marquez rdf:type foaf:Person
Simon Bolivar rdf:type foaf:Person
Simon Bolivar owl:sameAs https://viaf.org/viaf/35731693
Austin rdf:type schema:Place
Austin owl:sameAs https://www.geonames.org/4671654/austin.html
HRC University of Texas rdf:type crm:E74_Group
HRC University of Texas owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5671855
Politics rdf:type skos:Concept
Politics owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Politics
Gabriel Garcia Marquez Collection rdf:type crm:E78_Curated_Holding
Gabriel Garcia Marquez Collection owl:sameAs https://hrc.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/p15878coll51/
Subject Predicate Object
Documentary rdf:type schema:Movie
Documentary owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q22341402
Documentary crm:P102_has_title Gabo, la creación de Gabriel García Márquez
Documentary schema:genre Documentary Film
Documentary schema:countryOfOrigin Colombia
Documentary dcterms:language Spanish
Documentary dcterms:created 2015
Documentary schema:director Justin Webster
Documentary schema:duration PT90M
Documentary dcterms:subject Gabriel Garcia Marquez
Documentary schema:location Aracataca
Aracataca rdf:type schema:Place
Aracataca owl:sameAs https://www.geonames.org/3689760/aracataca.html
Justin Webster rdf:type foaf:Person
Justin Webster owl:sameAs https://viaf.org/viaf/90693839
Colombia rdf:type schema:Place
Colombia owl:sameAs https://www.geonames.org/3686110/republic-of-colombia.html
Subject Predicate Object
Illustration rdf:type schema:VisualArtwork
Illustration owl:sameAs https://blanton.emuseum.com/internal/media/dispatcher/
22398/full
Illustration crm:P102_has_title Daguerrotipo Coronel Aureliano Buendía
Illustration crm:P32_used_general_technique Daguerrotype
Illustration crm:P43_has_dimension 66 x 39.7
Illustration crm:E57_consist_of Ink on paper
Illustration dcterms:creator Melecio Galván
Illustration dcterms:created 1969
Illustration crm:P138_represents Coronel Aureliano Buendia
Illustration dcterms:relation Gabriel García Márquez
Daguerrotype crm:P14_carried_out_by Louis Jacques Mandé Daguerre
Daguerrotype rdf:type crm:E29 _Design_or_Procedure
Daguerrotype owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q179744
Louis Jacques Mandé
Daguerre
rdf:type foaf:Person
Louis Jacques Mandé
Daguerre
owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q131405
Melecio Galván rdf:type foaf:Person
Melecio Galván owl:sameAs http://viaf.org/viaf/73077858
Melecio Galván schema:hasOccupation Artist
Coronel Aureliano Buendía rdf:type frbrer:Character
Coronel Aureliano Buendía dcterms:isPartOf Cien años de soledad
Cien años de soledad rdf:type schema:Book
Cien años de soledad owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/One_Hundred_Years_of_Solitude
Subject Predicate Object
Image rdf:type schema:ImageObject
Image owl:sameAs https://lccn.loc.gov/2017645733
Image crm:P102_has_title Zona bananera
Image schema:locationCreated Ciénaga
Image schema:locationCreated Colombia
Image schema:locationCreated Zona bananera
Image dcterms:creator Leo Matiz
Image dcterms:created 1939
Image dcterms:issued 2017
Image crm:P43_has_dimension 40 x 31 cm
Image crm:E57_consist_of Giclee print
Image crm:P52_has_current_owner Library of Congress
Image dcterms:relation Gabriel García Márquez
Image crm:P67_refers_to Bananas Massacre
Ciénaga rdf:type schema:Place
Ciénaga owl:sameAs https://www.geonames.org/3686279/cienaga.html
Colombia rdf:type schema:Place
Colombia owl:sameAs https://www.geonames.org/3686110/republic-of-colombia.html
Library of Congress rdf:type crm:E74_Group
Library of Congress owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q131454
Leo Matiz rdf:type foaf:Person
Leo Matiz owl:sameAs http://viaf.org/viaf/18030004
Leo Matiz schema:hasOccupation Photographer
Leo Matiz schema:birthPlace Aracataca
Aracataca rdf:type schema:Place
Aracataca owl:sameAs https://www.geonames.org/3689760/aracataca.html
Zona bananera rdf:type schema:Place
Zona bananera owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2434796
Gabriel Garcia Marquez rdf:type foaf:Person
Gabriel Garcia Marquez owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5878
Banana's Massacre rdf:type crm:E5_Event
Banana's Massacre owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1134821
Banana's Massacre crm:P10_falls_within Colombian Armed Conflict
Colombian Armed Conflict rdf:type crm:E4_Period
Colombian Armed Conflict owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Colombian_conflict
Colombian Armed Conflict dcterms:relation Politics
Politics rdf:type skos:Concept
Politics owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Politics
Subject Predicate Object
Interview rdf:type schema:Article
Interview owl:sameAs http://hdl.handle.net/10366/61923
Interview crm:P102_has_title Gabriel García Márquez, la imaginación como arma política
Interview dcterms:language Spanish
Interview dcterms:creator Ernesto González Bermejo
Interview dcterms:publisher Revista Triunfo
Interview dcterms:issued 12/4/1975
Interview dcterms:subject Interview
Interview dcterms:extent 2 pages
Interview dcterms:format PDF/application
Interview schema:participant Gabriel García Márquez
Interview crm:P52_has_current_owner Repositorio Documental
Universidad de Salamanca
Interview schema:about Politics
Ernesto González Bermejo rdf:type foaf:Person
Ernesto González Bermejo owl:sameAs http://viaf.org/viaf/76347310
Ernesto González Bermejo schema:hasOccupation Journalist
Revista Triunfo rdf:type schema:Periodical
Revista Triunfo owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q9090224
Repositorio Documental
Universidad de Salamanca
rdf:type crm:E74_Group
Repositorio Documental
Universidad de Salamanca
owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q131454
Gabriel Garcia Marquez rdf:type foaf:Person
Gabriel Garcia Marquez owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5878
Politics rdf:type skos:Concept
Politics owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Politics
Subject Predicate Object
Letter rdf:type schema:Message
Letter owl:sameAs https://hrc.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/p15878coll51/id/39842/rec/57
Letter crm:P102_has_title Letter to Bochica (Comandante General)
Letter dcterms:language Spanish
Letter dcterms:extent 4 pages
Letter crm:P52_has_current_owner HRC, University of Texas
Letter dcterms:format Manuscript
Letter schema:about Statements
Letter crm:E57_consist_of Signed typescript
Letter dcterms:created 22-04-1996
Letter schema:sender Gabriel García Maárquez
Letter schema:recipient Hugo Antonio Toro Restrepo
Hugo Antonio Toro Restrepo rdf:type foaf:Person
Hugo Antonio Toro Restrepo owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q130732719
Hugo Antonio Toro Restrepo crm:P107_has_current_or_former_member JEGA (Movimiento Jorge Eliécer Gaitán)
JEGA (Movimiento Jorge Eliécer Gaitán) rdf:type crm:E74_Group
JEGA (Movimiento Jorge Eliécer Gaitán) crm:P10_falls_within Colombian Armed Conflict
Colombian Armed Conflict rdf:type crm:E4_Period
Colombian Armed Conflict owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Colombian_conflict
Colombian Armed Conflict dcterms:relation Politics
Politics rdf:type skos:concept
Politics owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Politics
HRC University of Texas rdf:type crm:E74_Group
HRC University of Texas owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5671855
Subject Predicate Object
Manuscript Hundred rdf:type schema:Manuscript
Manuscript Hundred owl:sameAs https://hrc.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/
id/395/rec/4
Manuscript Hundred crm:P102_has_title Cien anos de soledad
Manuscript Hundred dcterms:language Spanish
Manuscript Hundred dcterms:created 1966
Manuscript Hundred dcterms:format Manuscript
Manuscript Hundred dcterms:extent 493 pages
Manuscript Hundred dcterms:subject Bananeras Massacre
Manuscript Hundred crm:E57_consist_of Carbon typescript with light corrections by the author
Manuscript Hundred schema:location Macondo
Manuscript Hundred dcterms:subject Latin American Literature
Manuscript Hundred crm:P52_has_current_owner HRC, University of Texas
Manuscript Hundred dcterms:creator Gabriel García Márquez
Cien años de soledad rdf:type schema:Book
Cien años de soledad owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/One_Hundred_Years_of_Solitude
Cien años de soledad schema:about Magic Realism
Cien años de soledad schema:genre Fiction Novel
Magic Realism rdf:type skos:Concept
Magic Realism owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Magic_realism
HRC University of Texas rdf:type crm:E74_Group
HRC University of Texas owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5671855
Latin American Literature rdf:type skos:Concept
Latin American Literature owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1147454
Macondo rdf:type schema:Place
Macondo owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q934381
Macondo dcterms:relation Aracataca
Aracataca rdf:type schema:Place
Aracataca owl:sameAs https://www.geonames.org/3689760/aracataca.html
Bananeras Massacre rdf:type crm:E5_Event
Bananeras Massacre owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1134821
Subject Predicate Object
Nobel Speech rdf:type crm:E73_Information_Object
Nobel Speech dcterms:creator Gabriel Garcia Marquez
Nobel Speech crm:P102_has_title Audio recording of Nobel Prize in Literature speech
Nobel Speech schema:duration PT19M13S
Nobel Speech dcterms:extent 1 tape
Nobel Speech crm:P2_has_type Sound recordings
Nobel Speech dcterms:language Spanish
Nobel Speech schema:genre Speech
Nobel Speech dcterms:created 1982
Nobel Speech dcterms:isPartOf Gabriel Garcia Marquez Collection
Nobel Speech schema:countryOfOrigin Stokholm
Nobel Speech schema:about Magic Realism
Nobel Speech schema:about Social Criticism
Nobel Speech schema:recordedAt Nobel Ceremony
Magic Realism rdf:type skos:Concept
Magic Realism owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Category:Magic_realism
Social Criticism rdf:type skos:Concept
Social Criticism owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Social_criticism
Nobel Ceremony rdf:type crm:E5_Event
Nobel Ceremony owl:sameAs https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7191
Nobel Ceremony dcterms:created 1995
Stokholm rdf:type schema:Place
Stokholm owl:sameAs https://www.geonames.org/2673730/stockholm.html
Gabriel Garcia Marquez Collection rdf:type crm:E78_Curated_Holding
Gabriel Garcia Marquez Collection owl:sameAs https://hrc.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/p15878coll51/
Subject Predicate Object
Series rdf:type schema:TVSeries
Series owl:sameAs https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9892936/fullcredits/?ref_=tt_ov_st#cast
Series schema:director Alex García López
Series schema:director Laura Mora Ortega
Series schema:genre Political TV show, TV Drama
Series dcterms:language Spanish
Series dcterms:issued 2024
Series crm:P102_has_title Cien años de soledad
Series schema:productionCompany Dynamo CO
Series dcterms:publisher Netflix
Series schema:countryOfOrigin Colombia
Series crm:E57_consist_of Color
Series schema:about Social Criticism
Series schema:isBasedOn Cien años de soledad Book
Series schema:numberOfEpisodes 8 Episodes
Colombia rdf:type schema:Place
Colombia owl:sameAs https://www.geonames.org/3686110/republic-of-colombia.html
Alex García López rdf:type foaf:Person
Alex García López owl:sameAs https://www.imdb.com/es/name/nm3421685/?ref_=ttfc_fc_dr1
Laura Mora Ortega rdf:type foaf:Person
Laura Mora Ortega owl:sameAs https://www.imdb.com/es/name/nm2005384/?ref_=ttfc_fc_dr2
Social Criticism rdf:type skos:Concept
Social Criticism owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Social_criticism
Cien años de soledad rdf:type schema:Manuscript
Cien años de soledad owl:sameAs https://hrc.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/p15878coll79/
id/395/rec/4
Netflix rdf:type crm:E74_Group
Netflix owl:sameAs https://dbpedia.org/page/Netflix
Dynamo CO rdf:type crm:E74_Group
Dynamo CO owl:sameAs https://pro.imdb.com/company/co0231812?r=cons_ats_co_pro&
ref=cons_ats_co_pro


Metadata Alignment

After identifying the relevant standards, this final stage enables a comprehensive description and interconnection of the selected items. The project’s overarching aim has been to ensure coherent and interoperable data delivery by adopting widely recognized semantic ontologies. To structure the information effectively, all properties were organized into four categories: WHO, WHERE, WHEN, and WHAT.

  • Dublin Core: The Dublin Core Metadata Initiative (DCMI) Terms were selected for their broad applicability and established use in describing diverse types of resources through a standardized vocabulary.
  • Schema.org: Schema.org was chosen for its extensive and widely implemented schemas, which support the structuring of data across the web and enhance interoperability.
  • CIDOC CRM: The CIDOC Conceptual Reference Model (CRM) was adopted due to its suitability for cultural heritage contexts. As a domain-specific ontology, it supports the integration and contextualization of heterogeneous data from various institutions and disciplines—key requirements for this project.
  • FOAF: The Friend of a Friend (FOAF) ontology was included to model information about people and their relationships. It is particularly useful for describing individuals, their roles, and their connections within broader cultural and historical networks.

In instances where no direct metadata alignment was identified, "N/A" was indicated in the table below to reflect the absence of a suitable mapping.


Property Dublin Core Schema.org CIDOC-CRM FOAF
Creator dcterms:creator schema:creator E39 Actor + P94 has created foaf:maker
Institution/Repository dcterms:contributor schema:contributor E74 Group foaf:Organization
Publisher dc:publisher schema:publisher N/A N/A
Director N/A schema:director E39 Actor + P94 has created N/A
Member of dcterms:isPartOf schema:memberOf P107 has current or former member foaf:member
Owner dcterms:rightsHolder schema:owner P52 has current owner N/A
Made by dcterms:creator schema:manufacturer P14 carried out by foaf:maker
Sender dcterms:creator schema:sender N/A N/A
Recipient N/A schema:recipient N/A N/A
Company dcterms:publisher schema:productionCompany N/A foaf:Organization
Property Dublin Core Schema.org CIDOC-CRM FOAF
Location dcterms:place schema:location E53 Place + P55 has current location N/A
Country of Origin dcterms:spatial schema:countryOfOrigin E53 Place + P89 falls within N/A
Birth Place dcterms:spatial schema:birthPlace E67 Birth + P7 took place at foaf:based_near
Place of Publication dcterms:spatial schema:locationCreated E12 Production + P7 took place at N/A
Creation Location dcterms:spatial schema:locationCreated E65 Creation + P7 took place at N/A
Has current location dcterms:spatial schema:contentLocation E53 Place + P55 has current location N/A
Recorded at N/A schema:recordedAt E73 Information Object + P7 took place at N/A
Property Dublin Core Schema.org CIDOC-CRM FOAF
Creation Date dcterms:created schema:dateCreated E65 Creation N/A
Publication Date dcterms:issued schema:datePublished E12 Production N/A
Birth Date dcterms:date schema:birthDate E67 Birth foaf:birthday
Period dcterms:temporal schema:temporalCoverage P10_falls_within (E4 Period) N/A
Recorded At dcterms:spatial, dcterms:temporal schema:recordedAt P7 took place at + E52 Time-Span N/A
Property Dublin Core Schema.org CIDOC-CRM FOAF
Title dcterms:title schema:name P102 has title N/A
Subtitle N/A schema:alternateName P102 has title N/A
Type dcterms:type schema:additionalType E55 Type + P2 has type N/A
Dimension dcterms:medium schema:width, schema:height E54 Dimension +
P43 has dimension
N/A
Material N/A schema:material E57 Material + P45 consists of N/A
Genre dcterms:type schema:genre E55 Type + P2 has type N/A
Language dcterms:language schema:inLanguage P72 has language foaf:language
Duration dcterms:extent schema:duration N/A N/A
Subject dcterms:subject schema:about P129 is about N/A
Format dcterms:format schema:encodingFormat E55 Type N/A
Part Of dcterms:isPartOf schema:isPartOf P46 is composed of N/A
Represents N/A schema:representativeOfPage P138 represents N/A
Depicts N/A schema:depiction P62 depicts foaf:depiction
Technique N/A schema:artMedium P32 used general technique N/A
References dcterms:references schema:citation P67 refers to N/A
Discusses dcterms:description schema:about P129 is about N/A
Copyright dcterms:rights schema:copyrightHolder,
schema:license
P104 is subject to N/A
Edition dcterms:hasVersion schema:edition N/A N/A
Refers To dcterms:relation schema:isBasedOn P67 refers to N/A
Consists Of dcterms:hasPart schema:hasPart P46 is composed of N/A
Relation dcterms:relation N/A N/A N/A
Profession N/A schema:hasOccupation N/A N/A
Number of Episodes N/A schema:numberOfEpisodes E73 Information Object +
P57 has number of parts
N/A
Based On dcterms:source schema:isBasedOn P70 documents / P67 refers to N/A


Theoretical Model

The theoretical model provides a comprehensive overview expressed in natural language, outlining the properties associated with each entity and the semantic relationships between them. These relationships—visualized through pink arrows—illustrate how individuals, places, objects, and events are interconnected within Gabriel García Márquez’s literary and biographical universe.

The model responds to fundamental questions that guide the structure of the Linked Open Data (LOD) network:

  • WHO? Identifies individuals related to Gabriel García Márquez—both real and fictional—and specifies their roles (e.g., author, character, publisher, historical figure).
  • WHAT? Describes the nature of objects such as manuscripts, books, characters, and concepts, detailing their characteristics, types, and functions.
  • WHERE? Maps the locations connected to the author’s life, his works, and the archival documents, enabling spatial contextualization.
  • WHEN? Registers key dates and time periods—such as birth and publication dates, historical events, and narrative timelines—supporting temporal navigation.

Through this structured approach, the LOD Gabriel García Márquez project enables users to traverse the author’s intellectual and narrative networks in a meaningful and machine-readable way.



Enhanced E/R Model

Returning to the Entity/Relationship (E/R) model, additional layers of detail are incorporated to expand upon the structure previously outlined. This enhanced version aims to provide a more granular understanding of the relationships between entities and their associated attributes. By transitioning from descriptive natural language to a formalized schema, the model enables clearer identification of nodes (e.g., people, places, works, events) and the semantic connections that link them.



Mapping Triples

Ultimately, this formal mapping achieves the highest level of abstraction by adopting an ontological structure. It represents entities and their relationships using standardized classes and properties defined by authoritative institutions, while retaining literals when necessary. Clear relationships are established between subjects, predicates, and objects—whether entities or literals. The model is based on established schemas, ontologies, and controlled vocabularies, ensuring semantic consistency and interoperability with widely accepted Linked Open Data conventions.